Recoil Reduction Testing Results

Sponsored

When I started my journey to build a shotgun stock I had two goals: A) to build an adjustable stock that could be customized to fit a shooter’s unique size and shape and B) to reduce the ill effects that recoil has on a shooter by designing an effective recoil reduction system. 

While both objectives were intertwined and codependent upon each other for the ultimate success of my stock, perfecting the recoil absorption system was by far the most challenging aspect of the mission.

Sai Chiang

Sai Chiang

As shooters know, recoil is the kick you feel once the firing pin strikes the primer and ignites the shotshell’s powder forcing gas, wad, and shot down the barrel. 

Advertisement

Proper stock fit is one of the best ways to reduce recoil and that is why I decided to build an adjustable stock but the way that you hold the gun also can affect recoil greatly. 

While no device can eliminate recoil, there is no shortage of products on the market that claim they can dramatically reduce it. Aftermarket recoil pads and stocks with interior springs or pneumatic tubes work on the same principle. They compress under recoil and spread out the recoil. In the case of recoil pads, the recoil is spread across the length and width of the pad; while stocks with interior springs or pneumatic tubs spread it out even more because they spread the recoil along the length of the spring or tube as well as the recoil pad itself. Just how much recoil is reduced is often unknown as some manufacturers only state their product reduces recoil.  While some manufacturers who claim their device reduces recoil and this reduction is often shown as a percentage, they do not disclose how they came to their conclusion. 

The Grip Plus Recoil Reduction system uses an air-filled chamber that glides along a rail system dispersing the recoil throughout the length of the stock while the butt plate and comb remain stationary. This patented system combined with a custom grip, unparalleled adjustability, and a KICK-EZZ recoil pad has been praised by many of our customers as the “best recoil system” they ever experienced. While we at Grip Plus are pleased with the accolades, we wanted to know specifically how much each of our three shotgun stocks reduced recoil. Thus, in February of 2025 we put our stocks to the test by utilizing two different yet unique recoil testing systems. A shoulder mounted impact force measurement system from Recoil-IQ www.recoiliq.com and force measurement system from Loadstar Sensors mounted on a hands-free sled (see https://tinyurl.com/4j9nb4fn).

Dr. Mattew Hall, a faculty member in the Thermal/Fluids Systems program in the Department of Mechanical Engineering at the University of Texas, used one of the early versions of a Loadstar Sensor to measure the recoil force from a variety of shotguns. Dr. Hall and I shot skeet together at San Francisco Pacific Rod & Gun Club, when he was at UC Berkely in the 1980’s and he provided me insight on how to conduct our test and also how to build a measurement sled similar to the one he used. 

The Grip Plus Pro Stock.

The Grip Plus Pro Stock.

In a side-by-side comparison, we tested our Premier Stock, Supreme Stock and Pro Stock against the factory stockthat came standard on a 12-gauge over-under shotgun with a 32-inch barrel. After we tested the shotgun with its factory wooden stock we replaced the factory stock with our three stocks. All stocks were fitted with a one-inch KICK-EZZ recoil pad. 

The 12-gauge shotgun with its factory stock and Kick-EZZ recoil pad weighed 8 pounds/3 ounces.  

The Premier Stock and KICK-EZZ pad fitted on the 12-gauge test gun weighed 9 pounds/2 ounces.

The Supreme Stock and KICK+EZZ pad fitted on the weighed12-gauge test gun weighed 9 pounds/9 ounces. 

The Pro Stock and KICK+EZZ pad fitted on the 12 gauge test gun weighed 9/9 ounces. 

The Premier stock is our original and most popular stock purchased.  It features an air chamber with a Single O-Ring for a tight air seal. The liner motion components, guide rail, and bearings are all CNC milled from 7075 aircraft grade aluminum and 316 stainless-steel for optimal durability and balance. It features a custom Turkish Walnut pistol grip, stock, comb and KICK-EZZ recoil pad. Our Supreme and Pro models improve upon our premier mode by utilizing a larger air chamber for increased recoil mitigation. In addition to being CNC milled from 7075 aircraft grade aluminum and 316 stainless-steel, the GPS Recoil Supreme also features the use of Ti-5 Titanium for enhanced durability. 

Hence, the Supreme and Pro are heavier than the Premier. As we know, in addition to gun fit and grip, a heavier gun mitigates recoil better than a lighter gun. 

During our testing, we fired 10 shots for each stock using the same shotgun load: Federal Monark Target Loads, 12 Gauge, 2 ¾ inch 1 1/8 ounce, 1,200 FPD 8.5 shot;

We started our testing using the force measurement system from Loadstar Sensors mounted on a hands-free sled 

Loadstar Sensor testing results:

Advertisement
Stock12345678910Average
Factory11371265120612371199118212111205122012411210
Premier784803827825824836837814831803818
Supreme685694730709707715731726685661704
Pro526541478516493509545536501493513

To determine the amount of recoil decrease between the factory stock and the three Grip Plus stocks, we used a percentage decrease calculation which finds the decrease from one value to another in terms of a percentage.

By way of example, we have taken the average of the Factory Stocke 1210 (LB-F) and compared it against the average of the Premier Stock 818 (LB-F)

Calculate percentage change
from Starting Value = 1210
to Final Value = 818

(Final−Start)|Start|×100(Final−Start)|Start|×100

=(818−1210)|1210|×100=(818−1210)|1210|×100

=−3921210×100=−3921210×100

=−0.323967×100=−0.323967×100

=−32.3967%change=−32.3967%change

=32.3967%decrease

Grip Plus Premier stock reduced recoil by 32 percent versus the factory stock

Using the same calculation method:

The Grip Plus Supreme stock reduced recoil 41 percent versus the factory stock. 

The Grip Plus Pro stock reduced recoil 57 percent versus the factory stock.

Once we completed the hands-free sled mounted test using the force measurement system from Loadstar Sensors, we repeated our testing using the shoulder mounted impact force measurement system from Recoil-IQ. Again, we fired 10 shots for each stock.

Recoil-IQ Testing Results: 

Stock12345678910Average
Factory344404400384390407417418361428395
Premier239216227167197200178227153138194
Supreme84 79848376818184878282
Pro10110311510913511913992125125116

Again, to determine the amount of recoil decrease between the factory stock and the three Grip Plus stocks we used a percentage decrease calculation. Using this calculation the results showed: 

Grip Plus Premier stock reduced recoil 50 percent versus the factory stock.

The Grip Plus Supreme stock reduced recoil 79 percent versus the factory stock. 

The Grip Plus Pro stock reduced recoil 70 percent versus the factory stock.

The first thing you will notice in our two tests is the huge difference in recoil recorded between the two systems. As we noted earlier, a perfectly fitting gun, and a shooters grip will greatly reduce the amount of recoil. For our test, all four-test stocks were adjusted to fit my Length of Pull, and body type which greatly reduced to the amount of recoil calculated by Recoil-IQ.

The other result that may surprise you in the Recoil-IQ test is that our Supreme stock achieved a greater reduction in recoil than our Pro stock. As noted earlier, all three of our stocks’ air chambers were filled to 80 PSI to ensure that we were consistently comparing our different models. The Pro stock has the largest air chamber of our three models and can be filled with more air than the others thereby reducing more recoil. In our testing we discovered the optimal amount of PSI for the Pro model is 100. However, every shooter is different, and we encourage our customers to experiment with PSI levels to find the one that is best for them. 

Overall, I was very pleased with the testing results and gratified that we took the time and went to the expense to test our recoil systems. For years, our customers have been praising not only the custom fit they achieve with our stocks but also the recoil reduction they experience. However, in the past, we could only cite anecdotal evidence as to the effectiveness of our recoil systems. Now, I believe we have scientific evidence to back up our recoil reduction claims. 

I do realize that there is no perfect way to test recoil reduction as it is something that each shooter experiences differently. I am also aware that critics will find fault with each of our testing methods. I also know that there are many products sold today that claim they reduce recoil. However, few if any share information on how they have achieved the recoil reduction. Ask yourself why this is so. 

At Grip Plus we stand behind our products because we shoot our products.

Sai Chiang is the owner and founder of Grip Plus shotgun stocks. As an architectural fabricator, inventor and competitive shooter, Sai has devoted the past 18 years to designing and crafting highly customizable shotgun stocks with innovative recoil reduction technology that has earned four U.S. patents and one patent pending.

Discover more about Grip Plus at https://www.gripplus.com

Advertisement

Comments

    Leave a Reply

    XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

    Shotgun Life Newsletters

    Join an elite group of readers who receive their FREE e-letter every week from Shotgun Life. These readers gain a competitive advantage from the valuable advice delivered directly to their inbox. You'll discover ways to improve your shooting, learn about the best new products and how to easily maintain your shotgun so it's always reliable. If you strive to be a better shooter, then our FREE e-letters are for you.